Everything You’ve Ever Wanted To Know About Montreal Bagels

The only thing you need to know about Montreal bagels is that they are the best.

Move over New York City. We’ve got this.

But if you really want to be *the* Montreal bagel expert taster and fact-checker, read on. I went on a fun little tour named Beyond The Bagel: Montreal Jewish Food where I learned everything about the history and origins of this iconic dish, as well as that of other staples of Jewish cuisine.

I already knew the Mile-End, Plateau Mont-Royal, and Outremont areas quite well, since I live just 10 minutes away and some of my favourite restaurants and shops are located nearby. But a few minutes into this tour, I found out that what I thought I knew about the Jewish heritage in Montreal was, well, insignificant. I was excited to learn how the tight-knit Montreal Jewish community shaped the city as I know it today.

What’s The Deal With Montreal Bagels?

montreal bagels montreal bagels montreal bagels

montreal bagels
montreal bagels
 
montreal bagels montreal bagels

Anyone who’s ever known a Montrealer or stayed in Montreal for more than just a few days is familiar with the city’s longest-lasting battle: which is better, Fairmount or St-Viateur? These two bagel places are located just a few blocks away from each other, and they’ve been the subject of many debates, disagreements, break-ups, outrages, and family wars.

I’m barely exaggerating.

During the tour, I learned that part of what makes the Montreal bagel’s history so intricate is that no one, not even expert bagel-eaters (that’s a thing) can agree whether it was Fairmount or St-Viateur who brought the first bagels to the city. Records say that the first bagel bakery, aptly named “The Montreal Bagel Bakery”, set up shop in 1919 by Isadore Schlafman in an alley behind St-Laurent Boulevard. Meanwhile, Chaim Seligman was gallivanting all over the city with his horse-drawn carriage full of bagels, sold by the dozen. All was well in the Montreal bagelverse, until Seligman and Schlafman’s son, Jack, did business together but quickly quarreled and parted ways – anyone could’ve seen that coming! It wasn’t until 1949 that Schlafman bought a cottage in the Mile End, more specifically on Fairmount Street, and was blunt enough to go and name it “The Original Fairmount Bagel Bakery”. Soon after, in 1957, Seligman ditched the carriages and opened St-Viateur Bagel Shop with Holocaust survivor and Krakow-born Myer Lewkowicz.

And the rest is history! Montrealers have since been divided on the topic of bagels, and I don’t see how that this issue will be resolved in the near future. But secretly, I think it’s just an excuse to eat more bagels. Om nom nom.

And, as far as the bagels are concerned, the reason why they are better than New York’s (I am not letting this one go) is because they are poached in honey-infused boiling water, and then baked in a wood-fired oven. The result is a much sweeter, thinner (but not thinning!), and less dense bagel.

Smoked Meat, Bialys, Kokosh, And More Yummies

montreal bagels

Schwartz’s smoked meat

montreal bagels

Schwartz’s and its usual line-up

montreal bagels

Hof Kelsten bakery

montreal bagels

Timless Wilensky’s

montreal bagels

Wilensky’s

montreal bagels

Inside Cheskie’s

 

montreal bagels

Cheese crowns

No offense to the doughy goodness that are bagels, but this tour is called Beyond The Bagel, and so we went on to eat some other things.

Starting at Cheskie’s, a blink-and-you’ll-miss-it kosher bakery that describes itself as “a bakery for everyone”, seeing as it employs Venezuelans and Canadians of various religious confessions, not only Jews. The cheese crowns I tested consisted of a puff pastry filled with sweet cheese, which wasn’t something I was familiar with. Yummy!

Onwards to the iconic Wilensky’s Light Lunch, which has remained virtually unchanged since it opened its doors in 1932. It kind of feels like going back in time, a time where bologna sandwich and homemade egg sodas were all the rage. It’s one of the most iconic places in the Mile End, and yet, for some reason, I’d never gone inside until then. Needless to say it now features in my Montreal Cheap Eats list, at just $5 a sandwich.

And then, our guide took me to a place I would’ve never suspected would be on a Jewish food tour program, Hof Kelsten. The bakery is one of the trendiest in the city, not just in terms of popularity but also of design, and hipsters abound. It turns out that Jeffrey Finkelstein’s Jewish heritage inspired him to cook his mom’s brisket for a living and sell city’s only bialys, which medium-sized rolls filled with onions, either caramelized or raw, originating from Białystok in Poland.

Soon enough, it was time to say goodbye, but not before a mandatory stop at the bastion of Montreal’s Jewish cuisine, Schwartz’s. I’d never actually eaten there before because frankly, the super long queues filled with tourists always sort of discouraged me from going in. But when you are on a Jewish food tour, you don’t have to wait and you get to bypass everyone in line. YAAAAS. And then I understood why people queue. My smoked meat sandwich and pickle were both amazing!

Beyond The Bagel Food Tour – Good To Know

  • The tour lasts three hours and features quite a bit of walking, so wear comfortable shoes and bring an umbrella.
  • The tour visits non-kosher establishments and does not include gluten-free or vegan options.
  • You will be eating A LOT, so don’t overdue lunch or breakfast.
  • You will be given a bag at the beginning of the tour, which contains a bottle of water and extra paper bags if you want to get extra food from the tastings.

Beyond The Bagel Food Tour – Places Visited

Disclaimer: Viator is one of my clients as a freelancer and I was compensated to review the tour. All opinions are my own; I was delighted to explore this side of my city, which had remained very mysterious to me until then. Hurray for bagels!
 

things to do in montreal city guide

For even more things to do in Montreal as well as restaurant suggestions, local photography tips, pre-set itineraries, and exclusive discounts, get the Montreal city guide for just $9. It contains everything I know and love about Montreal!

5 Comments on Everything You’ve Ever Wanted To Know About Montreal Bagels

  1. Katie @ Second-Hand Hedgehog
    September 12, 2015 at 3:42 pm (2 years ago)

    So many photos of bagels! I’ve just eaten dinner, and they’re STILL making my mouth water! Though I do love a good tale of intrigue and rivalry… ;-)

    Reply
    • Marie-Eve
      September 30, 2015 at 11:08 am (2 years ago)

      One does not need to be hungry to eat bagels :-)

      Reply

3Pingbacks & Trackbacks on Everything You’ve Ever Wanted To Know About Montreal Bagels

  1. […] Every Montrealer I know has a favourite bagel shop and has unmistakably strong feelings about it. I personally am on Bagel Fairmount‘s team, simply for the friendly service and the fact that you are completely surrounded by ceiling-high columns of bagels when you enter the store; a lot of my friends, on the opposite, prefer Bagel St-Viateur, and you wouldn’t catch them so much as walking past Bagel Fairmount. […]

  2. […] the debate between the cities with the best bagels still remains to be settled — New York or Montreal? — if there’s one thing the […]

  3. […] in honey-infused water before they are baked, making them much sweeter than their NYC counterparts. To taste Montreal bagels, you basically have two […]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comment *






248 Shares